How-to Quotes
How to read a builder's quote
In brief
A usable quote names the licence holder, describes the work in enough detail that a second builder could price the same job, and separates fixed prices from allowances. Compare at least three written quotes against one written brief, and treat the cheapest with care. In Queensland, accepting a price below fair market value can reduce a later warranty claim.
A quote is a builder's description of the job they think you asked for. Reading one well is mostly a matter of finding the places where their description and yours have drifted apart.
Start with who is quoting
Look for the business name, the licence or registration number and the name of the licence holder. South Australia's licensing guidance says the licence number should appear on the written quote. Search the number on your state's register before you read further. In New South Wales, remember that a licence in an individual's name does not cover that person's company, so the name on the quote should be the name on the licence.
Then read the scope, slowly
NSW Government guidance says a contractor should give you a written quotation, and warns that if you did not specify exactly what you wanted at the start, the quote may only include the cheapest products and materials. Its instruction is to check that the materials quoted are what you asked for and not substitutes.
Go through the scope line by line against your brief and mark three things.
- What is named. "Supply and fix 19 mm tongue and groove hardwood flooring to living and hall" is a commitment. "Flooring as required" is not.
- What is excluded. Rubbish removal, painting, permits, asbestos, electrical and plumbing connections and making good are the usual omissions. An item that appears in neither the inclusions nor the exclusions will become an argument.
- What is an allowance. A prime cost item is a fitting you have not yet chosen, priced at an assumed figure. A provisional sum is work that cannot be measured yet, such as rock excavation. Both can rise. South Australia limits the builder's margin on such items to 15 per cent of the actual cost. Elsewhere, ask what margin applies and write it in.
Consumer Affairs Victoria suggests confirming whether a quote allows for changes that arise during the job and for delays to the quoted completion time. Ask for a start date and a duration in writing.
Compare like with like
Give at least three contractors identical information; NSW and Victoria both set three as the number. The QBCC adds that a contractor should see the site first-hand before pricing, because a quote prepared from a phone call is a guess.
Put the quotes side by side and make each one answer the same questions. Where one is silent on an item the others include, ask before you compare totals. A quote that is $6,000 cheaper and leaves out the electrician is not cheaper.
For a large project, Consumer Affairs Victoria suggests engaging an independent quantity surveyor to estimate the cost from your plans, which gives you a yardstick that no bidder supplied.
The trouble with the lowest price
NSW lists a quote that seems extremely low compared with the others as a warning sign in its own right. The QBCC tells owners not to base the decision solely on price, and gives a concrete reason: if you accept a quote below fair market value and later claim under the Queensland Home Warranty Scheme, the compensation you receive may be reduced.
A low quote is sometimes a better-run business. More often it is a missing item, a low allowance, or a builder who intends to recover the difference in variations.
Before you accept
A quote becomes binding terms once it is accepted, and above your state's threshold it must be turned into a written contract: more than $5,000 in New South Wales, more than $10,000 in Victoria, more than $3,300 in Queensland, and $20,000 or more in South Australia and Tasmania. If the builder proposes to start on the strength of the quote alone and the job is over the line, stop there.
Sources
- Getting quotes for contractors, NSW Government
- Contracts for residential building work, NSW Government
- Getting quotes for building and renovating, Consumer Affairs Victoria
- Seeking and comparing quotes, QBCC
- Building, extending and renovating a home, Consumer and Business Services (SA)
- Check occupational licence holders, SA.GOV.AU
State rules mentioned here are set out in full on our licensing pages: New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland.