How-to Quotes
How to write a job brief before you ask for quotes
In brief
A job brief is a written description of the work you want, given in identical form to every contractor who quotes. NSW advises writing one however small the project, and giving the same information to at least three contractors. A good brief names materials and fittings by brand and model, states what is excluded, and says when the work can be done.
Three builders visit the same bathroom on three different afternoons. Each listens to a slightly different description, notices different things, and goes away to price a slightly different job. A week later the owner has three numbers that cannot be compared, and chooses on instinct or on price.
The cure is one or two pages of plain writing, done before the first site visit.
What the regulators say
The NSW Government's advice is unambiguous: no matter how small the project, you should write a job brief. It can be anything from a few dot points to several pages, and it will help you clarify exactly what you want done. The same guidance says to provide at least 3 contractors with the same information so the quotes can be compared, and warns that if you do not specify exactly what you want at the beginning, the quote may only include the cheapest products and materials.
Consumer Affairs Victoria makes the matching point for larger jobs: ensure everything you want is clearly defined in your plans and specifications and conveyed to the builder. Its example of the level of definition is "a three-bedroom house with a seven-star energy rating".
A structure that works
1. The property. Address, age and construction of the house, and anything a contractor needs to know before they arrive: narrow side access, no off-street parking, a dog. State the year it was built. A contractor pricing work on a pre-1990 house has to allow for the possibility of asbestos, and one pricing paint removal on a pre-1970 house has to allow for lead.
2. The outcome. One paragraph on what you want at the end. "Replace the existing bathroom with a new one in the same footprint, with a walk-in shower in place of the bath."
3. The scope, room by room or trade by trade. List what is to be removed, what is to be built and what is to be reused. Be specific about quantities where you can: the number of power points, lights, taps and doors.
4. Materials and fittings. NSW suggests that, where possible, you list the brand names and models of the fittings, tiles and appliances you want. Do this for everything you have already chosen. For anything undecided, say so and ask the contractor to state the allowance they have made, so that each quote shows its assumptions.
5. What you will supply or do yourself. If you are buying the vanity, painting afterward or removing the old kitchen, write it down, along with who is responsible for making the two ends meet.
6. Exclusions. State what is not part of the job. An explicit list of exclusions prevents a contractor quietly including something you did not want, or leaving out something you assumed.
7. Paperwork. Ask each contractor to state in the quote their licence number, who will arrange any approvals and certificates, and whether warranty insurance applies to a job of this value.
8. Timing. When the site is available, any fixed dates, and when you would like the quote back.
9. Questions for the contractor. A short standard list makes the answers comparable. When could you start, and how long will it take? Who will be on site each day? Which parts will be subcontracted? What do you expect to find that is not visible now?
Changing your mind while quotes are out
NSW allows for this: changing your mind before the quote is finalised is fine, as long as you provide the changes to each person preparing a quote so they can adjust the price. The discipline is to send every change to everyone, in writing, on the same day. A brief that has been amended verbally with one builder is no longer one brief.
Plans and drawings
For anything structural or anything needing approval, the brief sits on top of drawings and a specification prepared by a designer, and the contractors quote from those. For a large project, Consumer Affairs Victoria suggests an independent quantity surveyor's estimate from the plans, so you have a cost figure that did not come from a bidder.
For smaller work a measured sketch, a set of photographs and the brief are enough. Mark up the photographs. A picture of a wall with "remove" written across it is hard to misunderstand.
After the quotes arrive
Read each quote against the brief, item by item, and note every departure. Where a contractor has suggested a different approach, take it seriously, since they may have seen something you did not, and then ask the others to price the same alternative. The brief you finish with, amended and agreed, becomes the scope attached to the contract.
Sources
- Getting quotes for contractors, NSW Government
- Contracts for residential building work, NSW Government
- Getting quotes for building and renovating, Consumer Affairs Victoria
- Asbestos in the home, Asbestos and Silica Safety and Eradication Agency
- Lead alert: the six step guide to painting your home, Australian Government
State rules mentioned here are set out in full on our licensing pages: New South Wales, Victoria.