Australian houses and the trades that keep them standing

Weatherboard JournalWEATHERBOARD JOURNAL

Fire

Bushfire Attack Levels, from BAL-LOW to Flame Zone

Six ratings decide how a house near the bush must be built. They measure heat, in kilowatts per square metre, and they say less about flames than most people assume.

Embers and radiant heat crossing the gap between bushland and a house
Distance from vegetation is one of the inputs. Embers cover the gap long before flames do. Drawing: Weatherboard Journal.

A house near the bush can burn without the fire front ever touching it. Embers do the work: burning bark and leaf carried ahead of the front, lodging in a gutter, under a deck, against a doormat or in the gap beneath a roller door, and smouldering there until the house is alight from within. The rating system used across Australia to decide how a house in a fire-prone area must be built is called the Bushfire Attack Level, and its lower rungs are almost entirely about that ember attack.

The six levels

The levels come from AS 3959, the standard for construction of buildings in bushfire-prone areas. Victoria's Building and Plumbing Commission publishes them as a chart, with the heat band and the regulator's description of risk for each.

LevelRadiant heatWhat the regulator says to expect
BAL-LOWNot significantRisk is very low and no specific construction is warranted, though ember attack may still occur
BAL-12.50 to 12.5 kW/m2Primarily ember attack; risk of radiant heat is considered low
BAL-1912.5 to 19 kW/m2Moderate risk, with more embers and burning debris and a growing likelihood of radiant heat
BAL-2919 to 29 kW/m2High risk, with embers, burning debris and increasing exposure to radiant heat
BAL-4029 to 40 kW/m2Very high risk, with some direct exposure to flames possible
BAL-FZ40 kW/m2 and aboveExtreme risk, with direct flame contact from the fire front likely

CSIRO's bushfire guide describes the top two in near-identical terms. At BAL-40, flames from the front "may intermittently contact the house". At BAL-FZ, the Flame Zone, they "are likely to engulf part or all of the house".

The unit is worth a moment. A kilowatt per square metre is a rate of heat arriving at a surface. CSIRO explains the figure for each level as the radiant heat that will be experienced at the house under that rating. The numbers in the names are thresholds, so a BAL-29 house is one designed for conditions up to 29 kW/m2.

How the level is worked out

The Victorian regulator lists the inputs: the Fire Danger Index for the district, the slope of the land, the type of vegetation around the site and how close that vegetation is to the building. CSIRO's online calculator asks for the same things, namely the Forest Fire Danger Index, the dominant classified vegetation type and the slope, and returns the distance from the vegetation at which each BAL applies.

Slope does more work than people expect, because fire travels faster uphill. A house above a forested gully faces a worse rating than one the same distance from identical bush on flat ground. Vegetation type matters in the same way. Forest carries more fuel than woodland, and woodland more than grassland.

The output is a set of contours. Close to the bush the rating is BAL-FZ; step back and it falls through BAL-40, BAL-29 and so on. On a large block that gives the owner a real choice. Shifting the house site back from the trees can change the rating, and with it the cost of every window, door and deck board.

CSIRO adds a caution that applies to every method. The BAL should be thought of as "a relative estimate of the potential exposure on your property, rather than a precise measurement". It is a design category. It is not a forecast of what any given fire will do.

What the rating changes

Under AS 3959 each step up the scale tightens the specification for the parts of the house that embers and heat attack first: the subfloor, external walls, windows and their screens, doors, vents, roof, gutters and attached structures such as decks and verandahs. At the low end the measures are mostly about keeping embers out of gaps and openings. Higher up, the materials themselves have to stand up to radiant heat, and at the Flame Zone the house is designed for direct flame contact.

The standard sets out the detail level by level, and a designer or bushfire consultant will translate your rating into a specification. Two general points are safe to make without the standard open on the bench. First, cost rises with the rating, and it rises steeply at the top. Second, the cheapest protection at any level is free: keep fuel away from the building. Mulch against the wall, a timber pile under the deck and a gutter full of leaves defeat an expensive window.

Bushfire-prone areas and overlays

Whether you need a BAL assessment at all depends on mapping. In Victoria, bushfire-prone areas have been designated across the state on the basis of weather, topography and vegetation. The Building and Plumbing Commission says that if you are going to build or rebuild within one, you will need a BAL assessment under AS 3959, and the result determines the type of construction needed to obtain a building permit. A separate planning control, the Bushfire Management Overlay, applies to higher-risk land and brings planning permit requirements with it. CSIRO notes that in an overlay area the council's planning scheme will in many instances set minimum requirements for your BAL and for defendable space.

New South Wales works through a document called Planning for Bush Fire Protection, produced by the NSW Rural Fire Service. The service describes it as a statutory document containing the specifications and requirements for building on bush fire prone land, and says the current legislated version, PBP 2019, was adopted in the planning regulations on 1 March 2020. If your land is mapped as bush fire prone, that document governs what the council or certifier will ask for.

Other states and territories keep their own maps and their own planning triggers. The first step everywhere is the same: check the mapping for the lot before you buy it or draw anything.

Getting an assessment

You can make a first estimate yourself with CSIRO's calculator, and it is worth doing early because it shows how the rating changes as the house moves around the block. For a building or planning application, CSIRO recommends an accredited bushfire consultant, who can provide the BAL assessment and the reports an overlay requires.

When you brief one, ask for the BAL at more than one house position, and ask what vegetation management the rating assumes. A BAL-29 result that depends on you keeping a cleared zone for the life of the house is a maintenance commitment as well as a construction standard.

Questions readers ask

Does BAL-LOW mean my house is safe from bushfire?

No. The Victorian regulator's description of BAL-LOW is that radiant heat is not significant enough to warrant specific construction requirements, but that ember attack may still occur. Embers travel well ahead of a fire front, so ordinary precautions such as clean gutters and clear ground near the walls still matter.

Can I work out my own BAL?

You can estimate it. CSIRO publishes a calculator based on the AS 3959 method, which takes the fire danger index, vegetation type and slope and returns the distances at which each level applies. For a permit application you will generally need an assessment from an accredited bushfire consultant or the process your state requires.

Sources

  1. Bushfire area overlays, Building and Plumbing Commission (Victoria)
  2. BAL assessment, CSIRO Bushfire best practice guide
  3. Building on bush fire prone land, NSW Rural Fire Service