Energy
Insulation and the seven-star rule
New Australian homes must now rate seven stars, not six. The batts that get them there only perform if they are installed with a care the trade has not always shown.
An uninsulated weatherboard house in July is a tent with a mortgage. Anyone who has rented one in Melbourne, Canberra or the Adelaide Hills knows the routine: the gas heater roars, the room is warm to shoulder height, and the moment it is switched off the cold walks back in through the ceiling. The physics has not changed since those houses were built. The rules for new ones have.
From six stars to seven
The Nationwide House Energy Rating Scheme, NatHERS, has rated the design of Australian homes since 1993. It gives a score out of ten stars based on the building shell, and the federal energy department describes what goes into that score as the home's design and construction materials, including walls, insulation, windows and roofs. A higher rating means the design needs less heating and cooling to stay comfortable.
With the 2022 edition of the National Construction Code, the minimum for new homes went from 6 stars to 7. The same update brought in a second measure, a Whole of Home rating, which looks beyond the shell to what is plugged into it. The department lists the energy performance of appliances for hot water, heating and cooling, along with solar generated on site and battery storage.
The changes were voluntary from 1 October 2022, with a transition period to 1 October 2023 that the department noted might vary by state and territory, and it did. If you are signing a building contract now, ask which edition of the code the design has been assessed against and what star rating the assessment produced. The certificate is a document you are entitled to see, and Consumer Affairs Victoria uses "a three-bedroom house with a seven-star energy rating" as its example of the kind of thing to write into a specification before you ask for quotes.
What an R-value is
Insulation is sold by R-value, a measure of resistance to heat flow. The federal YourHome guide puts the rule simply: the higher the R-value, the higher the level of insulation. For a given bulk material, doubling the thickness doubles the R-value.
Two versions of the number are in circulation, and confusing them is easy. The material R-value is printed on the pack and describes the product alone. The Total R-value describes a whole roof, wall or floor assembly, adding up every layer, from the cladding and air gaps to the lining. YourHome calls Total R-values the best indicator of performance, because they show how the insulation behaves within the building, and these are the values energy ratings and the code work with.
CSIRO's building technology guide divides products into two types. Bulk insulation, such as batts and blankets, is a low-density material made up largely of still air, and the way to get more resistance from it is to make it thicker. Reflective insulation uses a shiny surface, nearly always aluminium, to block radiant heat. Its resistance is, in CSIRO's words, "a property of the reflective airspace adjacent to the material rather than of the material itself". Foil with nothing but a hard surface pressed against it is not insulating much.
How much you need depends on where you are. YourHome says the appropriate level depends on climate, construction type and whether heating or cooling will be used, and that the code and, in New South Wales, BASIX set minimum Total R-values. It also suggests aiming above those minimums.
Where it goes wrong: installation
A batt has no moving parts and nothing to maintain. It can still fail on the day it is installed, and the code has a clause about how.
Clause 13.2.2 of the Housing Provisions says required insulation must abut or overlap adjoining insulation, must form a continuous barrier with the ceilings, walls and floors that make up the thermal envelope, and must not affect the safe or effective operation of a domestic service or fitting. Bulk insulation must be installed so that it "maintains its position and thickness". Where a ceiling is insulated and the external wall below is not, the ceiling insulation must overlap the wall by at least 50 mm. Sheets of reflective membrane must overlap by 150 mm or be taped.
Each of those phrases answers a fault that turns up in real roofs.
- Gaps. CSIRO notes that incomplete coverage of ceiling insulation leaves air gaps between batts. Heat takes the easy path, so a small uncovered area costs far more than its share of the ceiling.
- Compression. The code's explanatory note says the R-value of insulation is reduced if it is compressed, and that the space allowed must let it keep its full thickness. A thick batt jammed into a shallow wall frame does not deliver the number on the pack. YourHome's advice is to check the product has not been squashed in transport or storage before it goes in.
- The missing edge. Around the perimeter, where the roof pitch pinches down over the top plate, batts are often pushed short because the installer cannot reach. That strip above the wall is the part the 50 mm overlap rule exists for.
- Services. The code's note on safety names heating flues, recessed light fittings, light transformers and gas appliances as fittings that need appropriate clearance. Insulation packed over an old downlight is a fire risk; insulation cut too far back from one is a hole in the ceiling's performance. Both are common.
There is one more item for the frame. YourHome describes thermal bridges, pathways for heat through the components of a floor, wall or roof that bypass the insulation. The code deals with one of the worst: under metal roofing fixed to metal purlins, rafters or battens, a thermal break with an R-value of at least 0.2 must sit between the sheet and the frame.
Retrofitting an old house
None of the new-build rules compel you to insulate an existing house, but the same faults apply when you do, along with two extra hazards.
The first is what may already be in the ceiling. YourHome reminds installers that homes built before 1990 may contain asbestos in a range of materials, and that in some older homes loose-fill asbestos was used as ceiling insulation. If you find or suspect it, the guide says to consult a licensed asbestos assessor before going further.
The second is moisture. Insulating an old, leaky house changes where surfaces get cold and where water vapour condenses. A ceiling that used to be warmed by escaping heat becomes cold on its upper side once the batts are in, and a steamy bathroom venting into the roof space now has somewhere to condense. Deal with ventilation at the same time: an exhaust fan ducted to outside, not into the ceiling void. Our piece on condensation and mould covers the code's requirements.
For a timber-floored house the order of return is usually ceiling first, then draughts, then underfloor, then walls. Ceilings are the easiest to reach. Walls are the hardest, since weatherboards or internal linings have to come off, which makes a re-cladding or re-lining job the moment to do them.
When you get quotes for ceiling insulation, ask for the product and its R-value, the area in square metres, how downlights and flues will be treated, and whether the price includes going right to the eaves. Then put your head through the manhole before you pay.
Questions readers ask
Does the seven-star rule apply to my renovation?
The 7 star minimum described by the federal energy department is for new homes. How the code's energy provisions apply to alterations and additions depends on your state or territory and the size of the work, so ask your building surveyor or certifier at design stage.
Is foil insulation as good as batts?
They work differently. CSIRO says a reflective airspace typically has a thermal resistance similar to bulk insulation of the same thickness, but the performance belongs to the air gap beside the foil. Without that gap the foil has little to offer. Many roofs use both.
Sources
- National Construction Code updates mean energy efficiency ratings expansion for new residences, energy.gov.au
- Insulation, YourHome (Australian Government)
- Thermal Insulation, CSIRO Building Technology Resources
- NCC 2022 Housing Provisions, Part 13.2 Building fabric, Australian Building Codes Board
- Getting quotes for building and renovating, Consumer Affairs Victoria