Structure
Restumping: what goes on under an old house
Doors that bind, a hump in the hallway, a marble that rolls to the same corner every time. The trouble is rarely the floor. It is the ground, the water in it and the row of stumps in between.
Crawl under a timber-floored house built before the 1960s and you are looking at the cheapest structural system Australia ever produced. A grid of posts, originally red gum, jarrah, cypress or whatever durable timber the district grew, stands on or in the ground. Bearers sit across the posts, joists across the bearers, floorboards across the joists. Nothing is poured, almost nothing is hidden, and every part can be replaced with the house still standing on it. That last quality is why restumping exists as a trade at all.
It is also a job people buy badly. The symptoms show up indoors and the cause is outdoors and below, so the first quote tends to treat the stumps as the problem. Sometimes they are. Often the stumps are merely reporting what the soil has been doing.
Why floors move
CSIRO's homeowner guide on footings, written around the residential slabs and footings standard AS 2870, sorts the soil under most houses into two rough families, granular and clay, and spends nearly all its pages on the second. Clay takes up water slowly and swells, then gives it up slowly and shrinks. The guide notes that the movement is not usually noticeable unless a wet or dry spell runs for weeks or months, which is exactly the kind of weather this continent specialises in.
The pattern of movement matters more than the amount. Swelling starts at the edge of the building, where rain reaches the soil, and works inward. In the guide's words, wet periods first lift "the most exposed extremities of the footing system" and then the rest of the perimeter. Under a house on stumps the effect is different again, because each stump is its own small footing. Isolated piers rise more easily than the strip footings under the outside walls, and the result is what CSIRO calls a noticeable doming of the floor. Where summers are warm and wet, doming is the underlying tendency. Where summers are dry and winters cold and wet, moisture moves the other way and floors tend to dish.
So a hump down the middle of a Brisbane hallway and a sag along the middle of a Ballarat one can both be honest responses to the local climate. The guide lists the indoor tell-tales in plain terms, and the most common is a door binding on the upright of its frame.
Isolated piers that lose their footing will, in CSIRO's phrase, "eventually lose contact with the bearers they support and may tilt or fall over".
Water first, stumps second
Before anyone prices new stumps, walk the outside of the house in heavy rain. The CSIRO guide is blunt about where concentrated water comes from: gutters with the wrong fall, gutters full of leaves, corroded downpipes, and downpipes that discharge beside the wall instead of into a stormwater line. A leaking supply pipe or sewer will do the same work more quietly, and the guide observes that even a minuscule leak can be enough to saturate a clay foundation. Old sewer trenches, often poorly backfilled and running beside the footings, act as drains that deliver water straight to the subfloor.
Trees complicate it from both directions. Roots under a footing push up as they thicken. Roots beside it dry the clay and take support away. A leaking pipe then draws the roots toward the house, which is why the plumber and the arborist sometimes need to visit before the restumper.
The order of work that follows from this is simple enough. Fix the roof plumbing and connect the downpipes. Find and repair leaks. Give the ground a season to settle into its new moisture pattern if the house allows it. Then level the floor. A house packed level on saturated clay in August can be out again by March.
What a restump involves
The crew jacks the bearers a few millimetres clear, one section at a time, digs out each old stump, and sets a new one on a concrete pad at a depth the soil report or the building surveyor nominates. Concrete stumps are the usual replacement for rotted timber in the southern states; galvanised steel posts are common under highset houses in Queensland. Each new stump is cut or adjusted to a string line or laser, the bearer is lowered onto it, and the fixing between stump and bearer is made good.
Two details separate careful work from the rest. The first is the ant cap, the thin metal plate that sits between stump and bearer. It does not stop termites. It forces them to build their mud shelter tube out and around the edge of the plate, where an inspector can see it. A cap that is missing, rusted through or bridged by a stray offcut is worth nothing. The second is that a house lifted back to level after decades out of it will complain. Plaster cracks, cornices open, and doors that were planed to suit the old slope now show a wedge of daylight. A restumper who promises a dead-level floor with no cosmetic damage is promising two things that pull against each other, and a good one will tell you which they intend to favour.
What the code asks of the space underneath
New work has to meet the National Construction Code, and Part 6.2 of the Housing Provisions deals with subfloor ventilation. Its explanatory text gives the reason in a sentence: ground moisture rising into the subfloor creates a damp environment that encourages timber rot, fungus growth and termite activity. The amount of ventilation required depends on which of three humidity zones the house sits in. Openings must be spaced evenly as far as practicable and placed no more than 600 mm in from the corners, which is where still, damp air otherwise collects.
The same Part deals with clearance. A gap of 400 mm between the ground and the framing is required where a termite management system needs to be inspected, and on sloping sites that can reduce to 150 mm within 2 m of the external walls. CSIRO's termite guide gives the same 400 mm figure, measured to the underside of the bearer, and gives the reasons as lower humidity and ease of visual inspection. If your restumper proposes regrading soil under the house, or a previous owner has stacked pavers and old timber against the stumps, this is the number to hold them to.
A reblocked subfloor is also the moment to count the vents. Garden beds built up against the wall, a concrete path poured above the vent line and a deck added across the back are the three usual ways an old house loses its cross-flow.
Who is allowed to do it
Restumping is structural work, and the states treat it that way.
Victoria is the strictest we found. The Building and Plumbing Commission says owner-builders cannot carry out subfloor work such as re-stumping or re-blocking at all, and Consumer Affairs Victoria tells owner-builders to use registered builders to "reblock, restump, demolish or remove a home, regardless of the value of this work". A registered builder is otherwise required for domestic building work worth more than $10,000, and a contract above that figure must be a written major domestic building contract.
In Queensland a QBCC licence is needed for building work valued over $3,300, and a job above that amount must carry Queensland Home Warranty Scheme cover. In New South Wales a contractor licence is required for residential building work over $5,000 including GST. Restumping a whole house will clear all three figures comfortably, so the practical step is the same everywhere: look the contractor up on the public register before the deposit changes hands.
Ask each quoting contractor four things. How many stumps are included, and what is the rate for extras found once the floor is opened up? What footing depth has been allowed, and on whose advice? Who is arranging the building permit or approval where one is needed? And what is excluded: plaster repair, plumbing that has to be disconnected, re-fixing the verandah?
Questions readers ask
Can I replace a few stumps instead of all of them?
Yes, and it is often the right call where the failure is local, for instance beside a leaking shower or downpipe. The risk is mixing new rigid stumps with old ones that are still moving. Have the whole subfloor inspected and priced both ways, and fix the water source first so the new stumps are not set into ground that is about to change again.
How do I know whether cracks mean the stumps have failed?
Cracks alone do not tell you. CSIRO's footing guide ties most movement in houses on clay to seasonal moisture change, plumbing leaks and trees, all of which crack walls on sound stumps. Stumps that have rotted at ground level, tilted, or lost contact with the bearer are a separate finding, and you can only make it from underneath.
Sources
- Foundation Maintenance and Footing Performance, CSIRO Building Technology Resources
- Managing Termites, CSIRO Building Technology Resources
- NCC 2022 Housing Provisions, Part 6.2 Subfloor ventilation, Australian Building Codes Board
- Owner-builder eligibility, Building and Plumbing Commission
- Owner builders, Consumer Affairs Victoria
- Engaging a builder, Building and Plumbing Commission
- Who must hold a QBCC licence, Queensland Building and Construction Commission
- Checking your contractor or tradesperson is qualified, NSW Government
State rules mentioned here are set out in full on our licensing pages: Victoria, Queensland, New South Wales.