Australian houses and the trades that keep them standing

Weatherboard JournalWEATHERBOARD JOURNAL

How-to Disputes

How to make a complaint about building work

In brief

Raise the problem with the builder in writing first, because most regulators require you to have tried. If that fails, each state has a regulator that can inspect, conciliate or order rectification, backed by a tribunal or court. Time limits apply and some are short: 90 days for incomplete work in the Northern Territory, and three months for some Queensland warranty claims.

A building dispute is won or lost on paper, and most of the paper is created before anyone uses the word "complaint".

Step one: the builder, in writing

Every regulator starts in the same place. Victoria's dispute service says that before you can use it, you must first try to resolve the dispute with the other party yourself. Western Australia says the same of plumbing complaints: discussion with the contractor must be attempted in the first instance.

Write to the builder. List each defect or unfinished item, attach photographs, refer to the contract clause or specification it breaches, and give a reasonable date for a response. Keep it factual. That letter, and the reply or silence that follows, is the first document the regulator will ask for.

Step two: the regulator

JurisdictionWhere the complaint goesWhat can happen
NSWBuilding Commission NSWAn inspector meets both parties on site and may issue a rectification order; then the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal
VictoriaBuilding and Plumbing CommissionFree conciliation; binding dispute resolution orders, or a certificate for the tribunal
QueenslandQBCCA Direction to Rectify to the licensee; mediation and conciliation for contract disputes
Western AustraliaBuilding Commissioner, through Building and EnergyBuilding service complaints and home building work contract complaints
South AustraliaConsumer and Business ServicesConciliation, including compulsory conferences; enforcement through the Magistrates Court
TasmaniaConsumer, Building and Occupational ServicesMediation; inspection directions and orders
ACTAccess CanberraAssessment of complaints about building work and licensees
Northern TerritoryCommissioner of Residential Building DisputesDecisions on defective or incomplete work between owner and contractor

A few details repay knowing in advance.

In New South Wales, if you lodge a claim with the Tribunal after a rectification order is made, the order ceases to have effect and the Tribunal hears the matter.

In South Australia, a builder who fails to attend a compulsory conciliation conference without reasonable excuse can be fined up to $10,000.

In Western Australia, you do not have to be the builder's customer. Any person adversely affected by a building service can complain, and the regulator gives the example of a neighbour whose property was damaged.

In the Northern Territory, you must hold a fidelity fund certificate to apply to the Commissioner, and you must be able to show that the contract has ceased, that one party considers its obligations fulfilled, or that the relationship has broken down.

The time limits

Miss one of these and the best case in the world goes nowhere.

  • NSW: statutory warranties run six years for major defects and two years for others. The owner is responsible for applying to the Tribunal before the period expires.
  • Queensland: under the Home Warranty Scheme, claim a structural defect within 3 months of becoming aware of it; for incomplete work, lodge within 3 months after the day the contract ends.
  • Western Australia: building service complaints generally within six years of completion; contract complaints within three years of the contract date or of the cause arising.
  • Tasmania: inspection directions or orders can be issued up to two years after the Certificate of Completion.
  • Northern Territory: incomplete work within 90 days of the builder stopping; defective work within six years for structural defects and one year for non-structural.
  • Victoria: under Home Warranty, claims for defects within 12 months of becoming aware, and for incomplete work within 12 months of the triggering event.

What to bring

Victoria's regulator gives a list for warranty claims that serves for any complaint: your building contract, plans, specifications, payment records, photographs, reports and correspondence with your builder. Add the licence check you ran at the start, the insurance certificate, and every signed variation.

If you paid for independent inspections during the build, the reports now earn their fee. If you did not, commission one before you lodge. A regulator's inspector will form their own view, but a clear independent report frames the dispute.

While the dispute runs

Keep paying what is properly due, and take advice before withholding anything. Consumer Affairs Victoria warns specifically against withholding a progress payment over defects without legal advice. Keep the builder's access to the site open unless you have been advised to end the contract. NSW describes ending the contract as a last resort, to be considered only after careful thought, reasonable negotiation and specific legal advice.

Write down every conversation on the day it happens. Dates matter more than adjectives.

If the builder has gone

A builder who has become insolvent, died or disappeared changes the route. The claim is then on the state warranty scheme, not against the builder, and the scheme's own time limits apply. Our comparison of the state schemes sets out what each covers.

Sources

  1. Resolving building disputes, NSW Government
  2. Contracts for residential building work, NSW Government
  3. Dispute resolution services, Building and Plumbing Commission
  4. What Home Warranty may cover, Building and Plumbing Commission
  5. Time limits and amounts for Home Warranty, Building and Plumbing Commission
  6. During construction checklist, Consumer Affairs Victoria
  7. Defective work dispute, QBCC
  8. Time limits for cover and claims, QBCC
  9. Building dispute resolution, Government of Western Australia
  10. Plumbing work complaints, Government of Western Australia
  11. Building, extending and renovating a home, Consumer and Business Services (SA)
  12. Resolving a building dispute, Building Standards Tasmania
  13. Residential Building Consumer Guide, CBOS Tasmania
  14. Disputes and complaints, ACT Government
  15. Get defective or incomplete work fixed or paid out, Northern Territory Government