Australian houses and the trades that keep them standing

Weatherboard JournalWEATHERBOARD JOURNAL

How-to Contracts

How to handle variations to a building contract

In brief

A variation is a change to what the contract says will be built. It should be written down, priced, and signed by you and the builder before the changed work starts. NSW, Victoria and Tasmania all require this, and the written variation should show the effect on both the price and the completion date.

Budgets are rarely destroyed by one large decision. They go in instalments of "while you're at it", each agreed on site in thirty seconds and none of them written down until the final invoice.

What counts as a variation

NSW distinguishes two kinds of change. An addition is something you think of after signing and want added to the project. A variation is a change or adjustment to what has already been agreed. Either may come from you, or from the builder because of a council requirement or unforeseen circumstances. Both change the contract, and both should be documented the same way.

NSW adds a point about fault that owners overlook: if the reason for the variation is the builder's own mistake, you do not have to pay for the extra work to rectify the problem.

What the law requires

New South Wales. Variations must be in writing, attached to the contract, and signed by both you and the contracting builder or tradesperson, or their nominated supervisor or agent. Large job contracts must contain a clause saying exactly that. The document authorising a variation must explain its cost implications and the impact on the overall contract price, and the Government says the calculation of the price change should be shown, not just a dollar amount.

Victoria. By law you and your builder must agree in writing to the changes and put the details, including the new price and completion date, in your contract before the builder does the work. Where the builder orders a change you do not agree with, you must tell the builder in writing within five business days of receiving the notice.

Tasmania. The builder must give you a signed copy of the variation document within five business days of the change being agreed, and before any work on it commences.

What a variation document contains

NSW lists what the builder should give you before starting varied work:

  • a written description of the work;
  • any plans or specifications for it;
  • the extra cost, and any extra time required to complete the job.

Both parties sign if they agree. Add two things of your own: a running total of the contract price after this variation, and the new completion date. Number the variations in sequence. On a long renovation you may reach variation 14, and you will want to know there was no variation 9 you have forgotten.

The emergency exception

Sometimes there is no time for paperwork. NSW recognises this: if a variation is needed because there is likely to be danger to someone or damage to property, the written variation may be done after the work has been carried out. A burst pipe in the wall is an emergency. A decision to move a doorway is not.

Keeping variations down

NSW's advice before signing is to be confident you have thought of everything, because changing something later could blow out the budget. Consumer Affairs Victoria says to know exactly what you want and keep changes to a minimum.

Some practical ways to do that:

  1. Choose fittings before you sign. NSW suggests listing the brand names and models of fittings, tiles and appliances in the contract so the prices are accurate. Every prime cost allowance you can replace with a named product is one variation avoided.
  2. Walk the plans room by room. Count the power points, the light switches and the taps. Electrical extras are the most common small variation on any job.
  3. Ask about the unknowns. On an old house, ask the builder what they expect to find behind the walls and what allowance covers it.
  4. Ask the price first. Never say "just do it and let me know". The price you are told after the work is done is the price you have agreed to.

Extensions of time

A variation to the work often brings a variation to the finish date, and delay has rules of its own. In Victoria, where a builder wants to claim an extension of time, they must give the owner a claim within 15 business days after the delay ceases. Consumer Affairs Victoria says the owner should generally respond in writing within 10 days, either accepting or disputing the extension, and that if you do not respond the finish date will be adjusted as set out in the claim. Silence, in other words, is consent.

If you disagree

Put your objection in writing straight away and keep working through the contract's dispute clause. In New South Wales, arbitration clauses in home building contracts are void, so the route runs through the regulator and the tribunal. In Victoria the Building and Plumbing Commission offers free dispute resolution, and its Building Information Line is the place to ask before you agree to a price change you are unsure about.

Sources

  1. Contracts for residential building work, NSW Government
  2. Deposits and payments for building work, Consumer Affairs Victoria
  3. Building contracts, Consumer Affairs Victoria
  4. During construction checklist, Consumer Affairs Victoria
  5. Residential Building Consumer Guide, CBOS Tasmania
  6. Dispute resolution services, Building and Plumbing Commission