House types
Brick veneer: reading the cracks
The bricks on most Australian houses hold up nothing but themselves. Knowing that changes how you read a crack, and how much you should pay someone to worry about it.
Brick veneer is a timber house wearing a brick overcoat. The frame carries the roof, the ceilings and the wall linings. A single skin of brickwork stands outside it on the edge of the footing, separated from the frame by a cavity and held to it by metal ties. The bricks keep the weather off and the insurance premium down. Structurally they are passengers.
CSIRO's guide to footing performance makes the point in more careful language. Because the load-bearing structure of a brick veneer building is the frame, the building "can be expected to behave as a framed structure", except that the external masonry behaves like the outer leaf of a full masonry wall. Timber and steel frames, it notes, are less likely to crack from swelling and shrinking ground than masonry is, because they flex. So when the ground moves, the frame rides it and the brick skin, which cannot bend, cracks.
That is why a brick veneer house can show an alarming stepped crack beside a window while every door inside still closes. The crack is real. What it says about the building is usually less than it appears.
What moves the wall
The same CSIRO guide traces most movement to clay soil and water. Clay swells as it wets and shrinks as it dries, slowly, over weeks or months of sustained weather. The edges of the house feel it first. Swelling soil lifts the most exposed parts of the footing system and then works inward; a long dry spell reverses the process. A wall that is being lifted at one end and not the other has to accommodate the difference somewhere, and it does so at its weakest points, which are the openings.
The guide lists the classic signs: step cracking in the mortar beds in the body of a wall or above and below openings such as doors and windows, and vertical cracking in the bricks. Indoors, the companions are doors binding and cornice mitres opening.
Local causes sit on top of the seasonal cycle. CSIRO's list is practical: a leaking water service, sewer or stormwater pipe; gutters that overflow; downpipes that discharge beside the footing; and trees, whose roots both lift footings as they grow and dry the soil beneath them. A crack that appears at one corner in a wet year, next to a downpipe that has come off its connection, has more or less explained itself.
How bad is it? The crack categories
The footing standard AS 2870 classifies wall damage by crack width, and CSIRO reproduces the table. It is the most useful single piece of information an anxious owner can have.
| Crack width | What CSIRO's table says about it |
|---|---|
| Less than 0.1 mm | Negligible: hairline cracks |
| Less than 1 mm | Very slight: fine cracks which do not need repair |
| Less than 5 mm | Slight: cracks noticeable but easily filled; doors and windows stick slightly |
| 5 to 15 mm, or several cracks of 3 mm or more in a group | Moderate: cracks can be repaired and a small amount of wall may need replacing; doors and windows stick; service pipes can fracture; weathertightness often impaired |
| 15 to 25 mm, depending on the number of cracks | Severe: extensive repair involving breaking out and replacing sections of wall, especially over doors and windows; frames distort; walls lean or bulge noticeably |
The guide's own summary is reassuring: in general, most cracking found in masonry walls "is a cosmetic nuisance only and can be kept in repair or even ignored". A ruler and a pencil will tell you which row you are in. Mark the ends of the crack, write the date and the width beside it, and look again each season.
Monitoring is not a way of avoiding the issue. CSIRO says monitoring of cracks in walls and floors should always be treated seriously, and makes an observation about how cracks behave over time. Brickwork resists cracking where it can, so once a crack forms during a swelling cycle it tends to remain, at least in part, after the soil shrinks back. With repeated cycles the cracking often stabilises, because the wall has acquired the articulation it needs. A crack that opens and closes with the seasons and is no wider this March than last March is a joint the house has made for itself. A crack that grows year on year is something else.
What to do before anyone underpins anything
Underpinning is expensive and permanent, and it is frequently sold to people whose real problem is a blocked gutter. CSIRO's section on prevention and cure starts with plumbing, and so should you.
- Repair leaks in water, sewer and stormwater lines, and consider rerouting pipes and taps away from the wall where that is possible.
- Fix the roof drainage so that every downpipe is positively connected to stormwater.
- Deal with surface water. Where water flows toward the house, a grated drain connected to the stormwater system is, in the guide's words, usually an easy solution.
- Pave the perimeter sensibly. The guide recommends paving that extends at least 900 mm from the wall, more on highly reactive soil, with a minimum fall away from the building of 1 in 60, finished no less than 100 mm below the brick vent bases.
- Think about the trees. State agriculture departments can advise on root patterns, water demand and safe planting distances for most species.
Then wait and measure. If the crack stops growing, repair it. If it does not, you now have a year of dated measurements to hand a structural engineer, which will make their advice better and their fee smaller.
The cavity, the weep holes and the things that block them
The gap behind the bricks is a drain. Brickwork is not waterproof, so rain that soaks through runs down the back of the skin to a flashing at the base and out through weep holes, the open vertical joints left every few bricks along the bottom course. The current code's condensation provisions rely on the same principle: outside of single-skin masonry, where no pliable membrane is installed in an external wall, the water control layer must be separated from water-sensitive materials by a drained cavity.
Owners defeat this in two ways. The first is raising the ground. CSIRO's termite guide asks that soil and mulch be kept below the slab and away from the weep holes in brick veneer, for the sake of both drainage and inspection, since a buried weep hole is a concealed doorway for termites. The second is filling the weep holes with mortar or sealant to keep out spiders, mice or bushfire embers. Purpose-made screens exist for the last of those. A plugged weep hole simply stores water against the frame.
When to call an engineer
Go straight to a structural engineer, without the season of watching, if a crack is in the moderate or severe rows of the table, if a wall is visibly leaning or bulging, if brickwork above an opening has dropped, or if cracks are widening quickly. CSIRO reminds readers that external walls must still be capable of supporting themselves, and a veneer skin that has lost its ties or its bearing is a hazard whatever the frame is doing.
Choose an engineer who is paid for the report and nothing else. Advice on whether to underpin is worth most when it comes from someone who does not sell underpinning.
Questions readers ask
Should I fill a crack as soon as I see it?
Not immediately, unless water is getting in. Measure and date it first. CSIRO's table treats cracks under 1 mm as fine cracks that do not need repair, and a rigid filler in a crack that is still cycling will only crack again beside the repair.
Does a crack in the brickwork mean the frame is damaged?
Usually not. In brick veneer the frame is the load-bearing structure and CSIRO notes that framed buildings are less likely to crack from soil movement because they are flexible. Look for the indoor signs it lists, such as binding doors and opening cornice joints, to judge whether the frame has moved as well.